Full product information for this item, together with my review, my ranking of the product, and any reader comments, can be found at www.amazon.com.
The great Churchill scholar Martin Gilbert’s ‘complete’ history of the Second World War can perhaps be faulted on only one count: plodding.
This weakness in rhetorical strategy is also the virtue that sets this history of the Second War apart from others. A glimpse at the dated chapters in the table of contents is barely enough to prepare the reader for the cumulative impact of marching month by month through this great conflagration. One skips from one military theater to the next, always aligned with the same dates.
Thus, Gilbert allows the crushing burden of world war to settle upon the careful reader with devastating effect. One wonders how the world survived.
Survive it did, thanks in part—with apologies to doctrinaire oponents of ‘great men’ history-making—to decision-makers and opinion-shapers like Gilbert’s beloved Churchill. Still, the bulk of this work’s attention falls upon the generals. How could it be otherwise in a theater-movement-and-strategy approach? One follows the bloodied paths of armies who follow, to some degree at least, the edicts of generals who see dimly through their glasses and on their HQ maps. This, too, is a reality of war.
I highly recommend this book. It is not the view of the man in the foxhole or the nurse in the dressing station. It is, however, a bird’s-eye view of how the world tore itself to pieces and then stopped just before there was nothing left.
